In this post
You swipe a credit card all month. At the end, you pay the bill from your bank account. If a tracker counts both the swipes and the payment, your spending looks about twice as big as it really was.
A credit card bill payment is money moving from your bank to your card. It is not a new purchase. The purchases were already counted when you made them.
How the double count happens
Here is a made-up example. In one month you spend Rs 12,000 on a credit card across food, fuel and shopping. Your card issuer or bank texts you for each spend, so you have the purchases on record. Then you pay Rs 12,000 from your savings account. Your bank texts you a debit of Rs 12,000.
- Correct total: Rs 12,000, the purchases.
- Double-counted total: Rs 24,000, the purchases plus the payment.
- Side effect: a big debit with no category, which also throws off your budgets.
Nothing is wrong with the SMS. Each one is true on its own. The mistake is adding them together without noticing they describe the same rupees.
Two ways to count it right
- Count the swipes, skip the payment. You see spending on the day it happened, with its category. This is the more useful view and the one Raqm follows.
- Skip the swipes, count the payment. You lose the categories, because the payment says nothing about what you bought. It is rarely worth it.
How Raqm keeps card payments out of totals
Raqm keeps each card and bank account as its own account, using the bank name and the last four digits. When it sees a debit and a credit with the same amount, in different accounts of yours, within 24 hours, it treats them as a self-transfer. The pair is left out of spending totals. This is the same rule that handles moving money between your own bank accounts, covered in self-transfers, refunds and your real spending and on the smart matching page.
For a card bill, the two sides are the debit from your bank account and the payment-received credit on the card. If your card issuer sends an alert for that credit and Raqm reads it as a credit, the two are paired.
When the pair does not match
A few common cases leave a bank debit on its own:
- No credit alert from the card. Some issuers do not text for payments received.
- Late posting. The card may show the payment a day or two after your bank debited it, which is outside the 24-hour window.
- Different amounts. If your bank debit and the card credit do not match to the rupee, they are not paired.
- A card Raqm has not seen. Without any alert from that card, there is no card account to pair with.
In these cases the bill payment stays as an ordinary debit. Open it in the transaction list to check it. If it is a mistake you can delete it, because deletes are soft and can be restored from More. Your card purchases stay counted either way.
What this means for your budget
A budget only helps if each rupee is counted once. With card spends counted on the day you swipe, your Food or Shopping limit moves when you actually spend, not when the bill comes. That is the idea behind budgets that follow your pay cycle. It also means a large card bill landing right after payday does not look like a sudden jump in spending.
Example: your Food budget is Rs 8,000 for the cycle. You spend Rs 3,000 on the card early on. Your Food total shows Rs 3,000 now. When you pay the card bill later, Food stays at Rs 3,000, and the payment is not added anywhere.
A quick habit helps here. After you pay a card bill, glance at the transaction list the next day. A bill payment that has been paired is kept out of your totals. One that is still a plain debit tells you the card alert never arrived or did not match, and that is worth a look before you trust the month.
Related double counts to watch for
- Moving money between your own accounts. Same rule, same fix.
- Refunds. A refund should reduce the original category, not appear as income. Raqm links the refund to the purchase.
- Sharing a bill. If you paid for friends, only your share is your spending. See split and settle.
If you want a plain walkthrough of how the SMS becomes a transaction in the first place, read how to track expenses from bank SMS in India.
Raqm
Know where your money goes, automatically.
Bank SMS read on your phone, never uploaded. Join the waitlist.
Join the waitlistRaqm is pre-launch and Android first. See the download page for status, and the FAQ for supported banks.
Frequently asked questions
Not when it can pair it. A debit from your bank and a matching credit on the card, within 24 hours, are treated as a self-transfer and left out of totals.
Then there is no credit to pair with, and the bank debit stays as an ordinary transaction. You can review it and delete it if it is a duplicate.
Yes. Each card purchase is counted on the day you made it, with its own category. Only the bill payment is left out when it is paired.
Rahat Sayyed
Founder, Raqm
Founder of Raqm and maintainer of the open-source bank SMS parser behind it. Builds Raqm, an on-device expense tracker for India. Writes about money, privacy and the small details of reading bank SMS.